Critique of Yusuf Haddad's Doubts About the Existence of Contradictions in the Verses of the Qur'an

Saeed Abbasi Nia

Abstract


One of the miraculous aspects of the Qur'an that has been considered by thinkers since the beginning of Islam is its miracle in the guise of difference and the absence of contradiction. Due to a superficial analysis of the contents of the verses and the lack of correct principles and rules in the interpretation of the Qur'an, some Orientalists have been under the illusion of contradiction and have made contradictions about the Qur'an. One of them is Yusuf Haddad, who has attributed the existence of contradictions to the Qur'an, such as the creation of the earth and the sky, and the questioning or non-questioning on the Day of Judgment. In this article, while examining the doubts raised by him, he tries to state that the existence of any discrepancy and contradiction in the verses of the Holy Quran is nothing more than an illusion and the apparent contradiction that can be seen in the verses of the Holy Quran is removed with a little care and reflection.


Keywords


Quran; Doubts; Yousef Haddad; Orientalists of Contradiction

Full Text:

PDF

References


The Holy Quran

Abn Faris, 'Abi Alhusayn 'Ahmad Bin Zakariaa, 1404 Q.M, Almaejam Almiqyas Alghuh, Kitab Aintishar Alriwayat Al'iislamiat, Qm.

Abn Manzur, 1408 H, Lisan Alearab, Dar Al'ahya' Alearabii Lilturath, Bayrut, Ch Awlaan.

Alfarahidiu, Alkhalil, 1414 Q.M, Kitab Aleayn, Tahqiq Almahdi Almakhzumii, Wabraham Alsumarariu, 'Ansar Eusw, Qum.

Alfayumi,'Ahmad Bin Muhamad,1414 Qa.M, Almisbah Almunir, Muasis Dar Alhijrat, Qum,Altibeat Althaaniatu.

Alhaydri, Ealya', Alnaqd Alaistishraqiu Walkitab Alnazariu, 'Ahshahi Maearif Alquran, Bahr 94.

Alshararat, Eabd Aljabbar, 1416 Q.M, Dirasat Fi Alquran Alkarim, Jameiat Almuealimin, Muasis Alnashr Al'iislamii, Qim.

Altarihi, Fakhara Aldiyn, 1408 Q.M, Majlis Albahrayn, Tahqiq Alsyd 'Ahmad Alhusayni, Dar Nashr Althaqafat Al'iislamiat, Ch Dum.

Altiftazaniu, Saed Aldiyn, 1409 Q.M, Sharah Almuqasid, Tahqiq D. Eabd Alrahmin Eamirat, 'Ansar Sharif Radi, Qm. N.

Altubrusiu, Fadal Bin Hasan, 1406 Q.M, Majmae Albayan Fi Tafsir Alquran, Tahqiq Mahaliyun, Aintishar Eizat, Qim.

Altuburusiu, 'Ahmad, 1413 Q.M., 'Ietsam Ela Ahl Allijaj, Tahqiq 'Iibrahim Bihadiri, 'Iintshar Easw, Qim.

Alzamkhashariu, Jaraliluh, Baytana, Kashf Alhaqayiq Alghamidat Liltahmil, Dar Alkitab Alearabii, Bayrut.

Balaghi Alnajfii,Muhamad Jawad,Baytana,Tafsir Alrahmini Fi Tafsir Alquran, Maktab Almashaeir, Qum.

Hidad, Alarshm, Dart Yusif Dirat, 1982 M, Alquran Walkitab, 'Iisdarat Maktabat Bulin, Bayrut.

Klini, Muhamad Bin Yaequb, 1388 Qa.M, Alkafi, Tashihat Eali 'Akbar Alghafarii, Dar Alkutub Al'iislamiat, Tahran.

Maearif, Muhamad Hadi,1423 Q.M, Shabihat Warudud Hawl Alquran Alkarim,Muasasat Altawhid, Qim.

Makarim Shiraziun, Nasir, 1370 Sbahaan, Tafsir Namunat, Dar Alkutub Al'iislamiat, Tahran, Harahidahim.

Nahj Albalaghat 1387 H, Jameah Alsharif Alrady, Wadabath Alduktur Sibhi Salih, Bayrut.

Raghib Alasfhany, Alhusayn, 1416 Qa.M, Mufradat Ayat Alquran, Tahqiq Eadnan Aldaawidii, Dar Alshamiat, Bayrut.

Sadiqi, Muhamad, 1388 Sbahaan, Albashaarat Walmuqaranat, Mutbaeat Alghari, Alnajaf Ashrf.

Suti, Jalal Aldiyn Eabd Alrahmin, 1363 Sbahaan, Aldaru Almnthur, 'Ansar 'Amir Kabir, Tahran.

Tabtabayiyun, Muhamad Husayn, 1348, Almizan Fi Tafsir Alquran, Tarjamat Muhamad Jawad Hajati Krmany, Muasis Dar Aleilm, Qim.

Waqti, Muhamad Hasan, 1385 H, Alquran Walmustashriqun, Aintishar Busatan Kitab Qum Al'awl.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.18415/ijmmu.v8i4.2568

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2021 International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding (IJMMU) ISSN 2364-5369
https://ijmmu.com
editor@ijmmu.com
dx.doi.org/10.18415/ijmmu
facebook.com/ijmmu
Copyright © 2014-2018 IJMMU. All rights reserved.